Proposed Constitutional Reforms in France Ahead of 2027 Election
In anticipation of the 2027 Presidential Election, constitutional reform discussions are gaining traction in France. The French Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, established in 1789, asserts that all sovereignty fundamentally resides in the Nation, an abstract entity that expresses itself through its representatives. However, the current Constitution, enacted in 1958, attempts to balance this principle with the sovereignty of the people, as stated in Article 3: "national sovereignty belongs to the people, who exercise it through their representatives and by means of referendum."
Despite this constitutional framework, there exists a considerable gap between the principle of sovereignty and its actual application within French institutions. The people effectively exercise their sovereignty primarily when consulted, and even then, their decisions can be overturned. A notable example occurred in 2005 when the French electorate rejected the Treaty establishing a Constitution for Europe by a margin of 54.67 percent. Subsequently, in 2008, Parliament amended the Constitution to facilitate the ratification of the Treaty of Lisbon, which encompassed much of the rejected treaty's content. Since then, no national referendum has taken place.
Common Sense Shop
The United States of Common Sense
Amazon shopping links. Sponsor Complete!
The Constitution outlines two primary paths for amendment. Article 89 mandates that both houses of Parliament must approve any proposed amendment in identical terms, followed by either a referendum or, for government bills, a Congress vote requiring a three-fifths majority. Alternatively, Article 11 allows the President to propose certain bills directly to the electorate. General de Gaulle famously utilized this article in 1962 to establish the election of the President by direct universal suffrage. The Constitutional Council, tasked with ensuring laws comply with the Constitution, has ruled that it lacks jurisdiction over laws that represent a direct expression of national sovereignty.
Currently, Richard Ferrand, the President of the Constitutional Council, argues that only Article 89 can be used to amend the Constitution, a position supported by the Council in a letter dated October 26, 2026. However, in November 2025, the Senate declined to enshrine this exclusivity into the Constitution. To prevent the people's voice from being circumvented, five avenues for reform have been proposed, each evaluated against a criterion inspired by Montesquieu: whether the rule would be dangerous in the hands of the least trusted government.
One proposed avenue is a citizens' initiative referendum. The existing 'shared initiative' process requires support from 185 members of Parliament and nearly 4.8 million voters, a threshold that has never been met. The proposal suggests lowering the requirement to one million signatures, subject to prior review by the Constitutional Council. This change could empower citizens to have a more direct say in governance.
Concerns Over Democratic Processes in Governance
Additionally, the article highlights recent parliamentary practices that have raised concerns about democratic processes, such as the adoption of the State budget without a vote under Article 49, paragraph 3, where the Prime Minister can assert government responsibility on a text, making it deemed adopted unless a motion of censure is passed. Furthermore, Article 47 allows the budget to be enacted by ordinance if Parliament does not act within seventy days.
The proposed reforms do not address specific issues such as European Union relations, immigration, or public spending; rather, they focus on who ultimately decides these matters. They pave the way for a deeper restructuring of the State, emphasizing the common good and the principle of subsidiarity, which will ultimately be determined by the people.
The Common Sense Test
This article was originally published on Expert Analytical Association “Sovereignty.”
Maître Virginie de Araújo-Recchia, Attorney at the Paris Bar, Public Policy Analyst, Member of Sovereignty.




