Florida Tops Academic Freedom Rankings for Fifth Year, Heritage Report Shows
Florida has secured the top position in overall academic freedom for the fifth consecutive year, according to The Heritage Foundation’s 2026 Education Freedom Report Card. This annual report evaluates all 50 states and the District of Columbia based on five key criteria: school choice programs, teacher freedom, academic transparency, return on investment of the state’s education spending, and civics education.
Following Florida in the rankings are Arizona, Arkansas, Idaho, and Iowa, with Iowa notably improving its civics education ranking from 44th to 8th this past year. In contrast, the states that performed the worst include Massachusetts, Connecticut, Vermont, and Maine, with Maine remaining at the bottom for the second consecutive year.
Common Sense Shop
The United States of Common Sense
Amazon shopping links. Sponsor Complete!
Florida's standout performance is attributed to its top rankings in both school choice and transparency. Arizona leads in teacher freedom, while Idaho excels in return on state investment, and Louisiana ranks first in civics education. The report highlights a growing national concern regarding civics education, noting that only 22% of eighth-grade students demonstrate a proficient understanding of U.S. history.
Jonathan Butcher, acting director for Heritage’s Center for Education Policy, emphasized the need for lawmakers to prioritize civics instruction. He stated, "This experiment will fail if we do not help the next generation understand the fundamental pairings of faith and virtue, as well as freedom and responsibility."
Empowering States in Education Choices
As federal education regulations become less stringent, Kevin Roberts, president of The Heritage Foundation, urged states to reclaim their responsibilities regarding student education, particularly by expanding school choice options. He remarked, "More states need to provide families with K-12 education savings account programs that allow them to choose learning environments that align with their values and work best for their children."
The Common Sense Test
Florida’s broad school choice policies are a significant factor in its high ranking. Butcher noted, "Florida has one of the largest and most inclusive—in the true sense of the word—school choice environments in the country. Some other states have adopted education choice but put limits on how many students can exercise these options, creating a two-tiered system: those with choices and those without."
The Heritage Foundation’s Education Freedom Report Card aims to promote an educational system that reflects the American Founders’ vision of a "pluralistic, decentralized, and largely privatized patchwork of schools, academies, tutors, and church-based institutions." Butcher concluded, "Our report card should motivate lawmakers to improve academic transparency, make it easier for qualified professionals to enter the teaching workforce, adopt rigorous civics content, and create school choice opportunities that allow every child to participate."




