Costa Rican Detainee Dies in ICE Custody Amid Care Complaints
Carlos Josue Marchena Marchena, a 36-year-old Costa Rican man, was found unresponsive on September 18 at the Winn Correctional Center in Louisiana, marking the third death of a detainee at this facility in less than six months. According to his family, Marchena had repeatedly complained about not receiving proper care for his diabetes, including missed insulin shots and meals. Following his transfer to Winn, his health deteriorated rapidly, leading to his untimely death just days after his arrival.
ICE officials stated that lifesaving measures were initiated before Marchena was transported to a hospital, where he was pronounced dead. The official cause of death is pending a medical examination. Marchena's sister and girlfriend reported that he expressed concerns about not getting enough food and water to manage his type 1 diabetes, which is critical for maintaining stable blood sugar levels. His condition reportedly worsened after he was moved between various facilities, including one in Michigan.
Common Sense Shop
The United States of Common Sense
Amazon shopping links. Sponsor Complete!
The facility has faced scrutiny for failing to meet federal standards, particularly regarding medical care, as highlighted in a report by the Department of Homeland Security’s Office of Inspector General. This report noted that the facility had multiple violations, including inadequate food storage and insufficient medical documentation, which could jeopardize detainee health and safety.
Marchena is at least the 58th ICE detainee to die since President Trump resumed office in January 2025, according to tracking by the Associated Press. Advocates for immigrants argue that these deaths indicate a systemic failure to provide adequate care within the detention system, particularly as the administration continues its aggressive deportation policies.
Disputes Over Medical Care Standards
Despite the claims from Marchena's family, ICE maintains that he received appropriate medical care during his detention. However, medical experts emphasize that consistent access to food, water, and insulin is crucial for individuals with diabetes, especially under stress. Dr. Rajesh Garg, head of the diabetes unit at Harbor-UCLA Medical Center, noted that the lack of proper care can lead to severe health complications, including cardiac arrest.
The Common Sense Test
In the days leading up to his death, Marchena experienced significant health issues, including stomach pain, vomiting, and chills. His girlfriend, Ana Leon Castro, recounted a phone call just hours before his death in which he expressed frustration over the lack of effective treatment he was receiving. The circumstances surrounding Marchena's death raise serious questions about the conditions within ICE facilities and the adequacy of medical care provided to detainees.
Marchena's sister, Franciny, shared that her brother had four children and had requested bail and voluntary deportation back to Costa Rica, but these requests were denied. His prior misdemeanor convictions included retail fraud and property destruction, but his family argues that these should not have dictated the level of care he received while in custody. The ongoing scrutiny of ICE facilities underscores the urgent need for reform and accountability in the treatment of detainees, particularly those with medical conditions that require careful management.




