Federal Agencies Drop Trump Loyalty Question After Court Ruling
Federal agencies have begun to quietly remove what has been dubbed the Trump "loyalty question" from job applications, following a federal judge's ruling earlier this month that deemed the question likely unconstitutional. This question, introduced by the Trump administration last year, required job seekers to explain how they would help advance President Donald Trump’s priorities and to identify favorite executive orders, detailing how they would implement them if hired.
Under federal law, hiring and promotion within the civil service are intended to be based on merit rather than political allegiance. Ethics watchdogs and employee unions criticized the administration's inquiries as blatant attempts to politicize the federal workforce and eliminate candidates perceived as insufficiently loyal to the president.
Common Sense Shop
The United States of Common Sense
Amazon shopping links. Sponsor Complete!
The ruling from the federal judge sided with the unions, issuing a stay on September 11 that prevents the White House’s Office of Personnel Management (OPM) from using the loyalty question while the lawsuit is ongoing. The judge's order emphasized that civil service hiring should remain nonpartisan and merit-based, not influenced by political loyalty to Trump or the Republican Party.
Despite the Trump administration's history of disregarding court orders, it appears to be complying with the stay. In a status report filed with the court, the Justice Department confirmed that OPM had informed all federal agencies to refrain from using the loyalty question in new job postings. However, the removal process has not been without challenges. Officials have encountered difficulties in erasing the question from approximately 6,000 existing job listings, which could complicate ongoing hiring processes.
To mitigate potential issues, OPM instructed agencies to disregard any responses to the loyalty question but allowed the existing job postings to remain unchanged, as most would close by the end of September. A source involved in the litigation indicated that only five new job postings have included the loyalty question since the judge's stay, suggesting that efforts to eliminate it are underway.
Revised Inquiry for Future Job Postings
For future job postings, OPM has advised agencies to replace the loyalty question with a revised inquiry that is less politically charged: "In this role, you will be expected to professionally and efficiently implement executive direction. Provide an example where you implemented leadership direction on a strategy or policy decision that differed from your own recommendation." This adjustment aims to maintain a level of professionalism without the overt political implications of the previous question.
The administration may still pursue legal avenues to reinstate the original question, but the presiding judge, George A. O’Toole Jr., indicated that the unions are likely to succeed in their constitutional arguments against it. Democracy Forward, a public-interest legal group representing the unions, stated that the stay protects the Constitution, the integrity of the civil service, and the interests of those who rely on a nonpartisan federal workforce.
The Common Sense Test
Originally rolled out in May 2025 as part of a so-called "merit hiring plan," the loyalty question was characterized as a short, free-response essay question. Critics quickly labeled it the "loyalty question," arguing that it imposed an unconstitutional condition on employment by selecting applicants based on their political beliefs and loyalties. After facing backlash, the administration claimed that answering the question was optional, yet many applicants likely feared that failing to provide a favorable response would jeopardize their chances of being hired.
One Department of Education employee expressed in a court declaration that the loyalty question created a moral dilemma for him, preventing him from applying for new federal positions. He stated, "Honesty is important to me, and I cannot in good conscience pretend to agree with President Trump’s policies. Even if the question is supposed to be optional, I believe it would be used against me if I don’t answer. After all, the question is there for a reason."




