Understanding Originalism: A Conservative View on Constitutional Law
The U.S. Supreme Court is set to return from its summer recess on October 5, 2026, marking the beginning of a new term filled with legal battles. As court watchers prepare for the upcoming cases, discussions surrounding the concept of "originalism" are likely to resurface in the media.
Originalism is the judicial philosophy adhered to by a majority of the current Supreme Court justices, yet it remains poorly understood outside of legal circles. As a law professor who worked under Justice Antonin Scalia, the most prominent advocate of originalism, I aim to clarify its significance. Scalia famously referred to originalism as "the lesser evil," and I will explain why this perspective is essential in today’s legal landscape.
Common Sense Shop
The United States of Common Sense
Amazon shopping links. Sponsor Complete!
At its core, originalism posits that the Constitution should be interpreted according to the understanding of those who drafted and ratified it. This contrasts sharply with the opposing view known as "living constitutionalism," which allows judges to reinterpret the Constitution to meet contemporary societal needs. While originalism has been a foundational principle since the nation’s inception, it waned in popularity throughout the 20th century, particularly during the era of Chief Justice Earl Warren, when the Court began to discover new rights not previously recognized.
A pivotal moment for originalism occurred in 1986, when President Ronald Reagan appointed Scalia to the Supreme Court. Scalia’s articulate defense of originalism shifted many perspectives within the judiciary. Today, several justices, including Amy Coney Barrett, a former clerk for Scalia, subscribe to this philosophy.
One common misconception about originalism is that it suggests the Constitution is immutable, or "trapped in amber." In reality, originalists believe that the Constitution can change, but only through the formal amendment process as outlined by the framers. In contrast, living constitutionalists argue that judges should have the authority to reinterpret the Constitution as societal values evolve. This fundamental disagreement raises critical questions about the role of unelected judges in shaping law.
Challenges in Interpreting Original Intent
Critics of originalism often point to the difficulty of determining the original intent of the Constitution's authors, given the historical context and the vagueness of some language. For instance, issues like abortion and gun rights have evolved significantly since the Constitution was written, leading to debates about how originalists should interpret these matters. Originalists argue that, despite the challenges, their approach is more democratic than allowing judges to impose their personal views on the law.
Another criticism is the historical context in which the Constitution was written, a time when many groups, including women and African Americans, were excluded from the democratic process. Critics question how originalists can claim their approach is more democratic when the document itself reflects those inequities. Originalists counter that the Constitution has been amended to expand rights, and the framework remains fundamentally legitimate, even if some provisions may not reflect contemporary values.
The Common Sense Test
In recent years, originalism has gained traction not only within the Supreme Court but also among lower court judges and legal scholars. However, as originalism becomes more prevalent, disagreements about its application have emerged, suggesting that the philosophy is more nuanced than initially perceived. While Scalia's approach simplified the concept, the reality of originalism may be more complex, as even he acknowledged the burdensome nature of the amendment process.
Ultimately, originalism presents a compelling argument for a more democratic interpretation of the Constitution. By advocating for changes to come from the people through amendments rather than judicial reinterpretation, originalists uphold the principle that the Constitution should reflect the will of the electorate, not the preferences of a select few judges. As the Supreme Court continues to grapple with significant constitutional questions, understanding originalism will be crucial for those who wish to engage meaningfully in the legal and political discourse surrounding our nation's foundational document.




