New Bill Aims to Block Foreign Piracy Websites Amid Censorship Concerns
The Deterring Extraterritorial Foreign Exploitation of Networks Damaging Intellectual Property Act, commonly known as DEFEND IP, was recently introduced in Congress by Senator Thom Tillis and Representative Zoe Lofgren. This legislation aims to give U.S. federal courts the authority to issue site-blocking orders against foreign piracy websites, a move that has sparked significant debate regarding its implications for free speech and censorship.
The bill amalgamates two earlier proposals: Lofgren's Foreign Anti-Digital Piracy Act and Tillis's Block BEARD. With backing from over a dozen industry organizations, including the Motion Picture Association and the Recording Industry Association of America, the bill is being promoted as a targeted approach to combat foreign piracy while ostensibly protecting Americans' access to a free and open internet.
Common Sense Shop
The United States of Common Sense
Amazon shopping links. Sponsor Complete!
Under DEFEND IP, broadband providers with at least 50,000 subscribers and public DNS resolvers generating over $100 million in annual revenue would be required to comply with court orders to block designated sites. Notably, the bill exempts entities that provide virtual private network (VPN) services or those that operate exclusively through encrypted DNS protocols, suggesting a recognition of the potential for users to circumvent such blocks.
Critics, however, argue that these exemptions highlight the bill's shortcomings, indicating that it may not effectively halt piracy as intended. Meredith Rose, Senior Policy Counsel at Public Knowledge, expressed concerns that the legislation could create a framework for censorship rather than genuinely addressing the piracy issue. She noted that the bill's design allows for the possibility of users accessing blocked sites through VPNs, undermining the bill's stated purpose.
Legislative Process Raises Due Process Concerns
The process outlined in the legislation mandates that a U.S. federal court must first designate a site as a "foreign digital piracy site" before a rightsholder can seek a blocking order. This designation can occur without the site operator present, raising concerns about due process. Once designated, the rightsholder can obtain a blocking order, which could be issued preemptively for live events expected to be transmitted illegally.
Supporters of the bill argue that the two-step court process and exemptions for VPNs and encrypted DNS are sufficient safeguards. Yet, the reality remains that the bill could lead to widespread censorship, as it compels service providers to act as enforcers of copyright law without adequate checks against potential abuse. The lack of penalties for wrongful blocking further complicates the matter, as businesses could face significant disruptions without recourse.
The Common Sense Test
The introduction of DEFEND IP aligns with a broader trend in legislative efforts to strengthen intellectual property rights enforcement, as seen in the recently proposed American Copyright Protection Act. However, this new bill's approach raises critical questions about the balance between protecting intellectual property and ensuring that free speech rights are not unduly compromised.
As discussions around the bill continue, the implications for internet freedom and the potential for overreach in censorship remain at the forefront of the debate. The balance between protecting intellectual property and safeguarding individual liberties is a delicate one, and as this legislation progresses, it will be crucial to monitor how these tensions play out in the legislative arena.




