Education Savings Accounts Demand Charter School Flexibility
In a 2001 interview, economist Milton Friedman reflected on his vision of a universal school voucher system, which he had popularized decades earlier. At that time, progress toward this vision was slow, with only about 1 percent of public school students enrolled in charter schools. Friedman described charter schools as a "halfway house," indicating that they still operated under government oversight.
Fast forward to today, and Friedman's vision of educational freedom is becoming a reality. Twelve states now offer education savings accounts (ESAs) with universal eligibility, allowing families to use funds for a variety of educational expenses beyond just private school tuition. This includes tutoring, textbooks, online courses, and more, significantly broadening the educational options available to families.
Common Sense Shop
The United States of Common Sense
Amazon shopping links. Sponsor Complete!
Despite this progress, there has been surprisingly little discussion about what these changes mean for charter schools, which have long been the primary publicly financed alternative to traditional district schools. To explore this issue, I, along with Auburn professor David Marshall, surveyed 285 charter school leaders across Arizona, Florida, and Utah—states that have recently enacted universal ESA programs. Our survey aimed to determine whether charter schools need to adapt in light of these new educational options.
The results were telling: about two-thirds of respondents indicated that the charter sector should become less bureaucratic and allow for greater autonomy. Furthermore, 36 percent of those surveyed stated they would have considered opening a nonpublic school, such as a private or microschool, had universal ESAs been available when they established their charter schools. In Arizona, where the universal ESA program has been in place the longest, 42 percent of respondents expressed interest in nonpublic school options, indicating a significant shift in sentiment.
The introduction of universal ESAs has expanded educational choices for families and potential school founders, yet it has left existing charter schools in a bind. These institutions were created under a policy framework where becoming a charter school was often the only viable way to operate a publicly funded school outside of traditional district systems. Today, an entrepreneur might opt for a private school model funded by ESA payments instead of pursuing a charter.
Charter Schools' Unique Challenges Explained
Charter schools face obligations that private schools do not, such as testing mandates and requirements to serve students with special needs. These constraints were acceptable when public funding was the only option, but the advent of universal ESAs alters that equation. Therefore, states with universal ESAs should consider creating pathways for charter schools to convert to private institutions voluntarily.
For instance, a school entrepreneur aiming to establish a Montessori school may find that the practices inherent to Montessori education do not align well with public schooling structures. Charter Montessori schools must navigate the same accountability frameworks as other charters, often forcing leaders to choose between maintaining fidelity to the Montessori model and meeting state testing requirements.
Alternatively, some charter leaders may prefer to remain within the public system to access additional funding and special education services. This proposed pathway for conversion would allow schools that prioritize maximum freedom to exit the charter system while enabling those that value public funding to remain charters.
The Common Sense Test
However, any conversion must be carefully managed to avoid simply transferring public assets to private entities. States would need to establish clear guidelines governing property and resources purchased with taxpayer dollars, ensuring a smooth transition for currently enrolled families.
These complexities, while significant, are not insurmountable. As states continue to redefine the rules of school choice, it is only fair to allow existing charter schools the opportunity to reassess their operational choices based on the current educational landscape. After all, educational freedom should extend beyond the schoolhouse door.




