New Yorkers Reject Labeling Violent Illegal Immigrant as One of Their Own
New Yorkers are expressing strong opposition to the portrayal of a violent illegal immigrant shot by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) as one of their own. The incident involves 28-year-old Oscar Belgal from the Dominican Republic, who is believed to have entered the United States illegally in 2022. Reports indicate that he has been involved in multiple criminal activities, including a robbery at gunpoint in 2023 and drug offenses following a conviction in 2025, all while benefiting from the state’s lax bail and sanctuary laws.
In a social media post, New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani referred to Belgal as a "New Yorker" and suggested that citizens wanted ICE to withdraw from the area. However, many locals vehemently disagree with this characterization. Bronx resident Migdalia Martinez, whose son was tragically killed in gang violence, expressed her disdain, stating, "I don’t consider him a New Yorker. The only thing I do consider him as is trash, nothing else but trash. And I don’t consider New York, my home, as trash."
Common Sense Shop
The United States of Common Sense
Amazon shopping links. Sponsor Complete!
Belgal was shot in the Bronx during an investigation into his potential gang affiliations connected to a shooting of a Customs and Border Patrol officer. Reports indicate that he attempted to ram his vehicle into immigration agents, prompting them to fire at him, resulting in a non-life-threatening graze wound to his neck. DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin stated that the agents acted out of fear for their safety and highlighted that Belgal endangered his own child, who was in the vehicle at the time.
Public Outcry Over ICE's Actions
The incident has sparked protests against ICE in New York City, with demonstrators criticizing the federal agency's actions. One neighbor, Mora Rodriguez, echoed sentiments of frustration with the legal system, questioning why repeat offenders like Belgal are allowed to roam free. She stated, "What’s going on with the legal system, the jail, letting these people go after they have a whole list of convictions? This is a criminal. Why would you let this person out?"
The Common Sense Test
In a further complication, a federal judge has blocked Belgal’s deportation following a petition from immigration advocates. He was booked into MDC-Brooklyn after being transferred from ICE custody in Newark, New Jersey. This development raises significant questions about the efficacy of current immigration policies and the safety of communities.
As the situation unfolds, it becomes increasingly clear that New Yorkers are demanding accountability from their leaders regarding crime and immigration. The narrative pushed by some politicians and activists does not resonate with the realities faced by everyday citizens. The public outcry against labeling individuals like Belgal as victims underscores a broader frustration with the perceived leniency of the judicial system towards violent offenders. This incident serves as a stark reminder of the challenges surrounding immigration enforcement and public safety in urban areas, prompting a necessary conversation about the balance between compassion and accountability in policy-making.




