Mamdani Initiates Review of NYPD Use-of-Force Policies
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani has ordered a review of the New York City Police Department’s (NYPD) use of force for the first time in a decade. This decision comes amid mounting pressure from his progressive base advocating for significant law enforcement reforms. On Monday, the city announced it would introduce a "package of reforms" alongside the review, aimed at strengthening accountability when police officers face serious misconduct allegations.
The NYPD, recognized as the largest police force in the United States, has faced scrutiny following the retirement of an officer involved in the shooting death of 19-year-old Win Rozario during a mental health crisis in 2024. The mayor's office noted that the officer retired before a disciplinary trial could occur, raising concerns about accountability.
Common Sense Shop
The United States of Common Sense
Amazon shopping links. Sponsor Complete!
Among the reforms announced by Mamdani is an allocation of $2.6 million in additional funding for the Office of the Inspector General, which is responsible for investigating NYPD policies and misconduct. Furthermore, the statement included plans for a new notification system designed to ensure that disciplinary hearings are completed prior to an officer's retirement. There is also a renewed emphasis on the NYPD's compliance with state-level reporting requirements regarding police-involved deaths.
This announcement follows increased pressure from Mamdani’s fellow progressives to enforce greater accountability within the NYPD. A significant focus has been on the Strategic Response Group, a specialized unit tasked with handling protests and major events. Earlier this month, 17 state-level politicians, including congressional candidates Claire Valdez and Darializa Avila Chevalier, called for the disbandment of this unit, which they claim has been involved in excessive force during protests against a recent ICE operation.
The protests were ignited by an incident on October 8, when an ICE officer shot 28-year-old Oscar Belgal while he was in an SUV with his five-year-old son. This incident led to widespread demonstrations against ICE's tactics and the police response that followed. Chevalier, who was present during the protests, reported experiencing police aggression firsthand, stating that she was "shoved to the ground by an officer" and witnessed other instances of excessive violence.
Calls for Enhanced Police Oversight
Mamdani condemned the shooting and called for Belgal’s release from federal custody, aligning himself with critics who argue that such incidents underscore the need for enhanced police oversight. Reported use of force incidents within the NYPD have surged over the past decade, with 12,348 incidents reported in 2025 compared to 4,087 in 2016, the year the department began tracking these statistics.
Despite the increase in use-of-force incidents, crime rates in New York City have shown a downward trend. Recent reports indicate that the city has experienced the "fewest shooting incidents, shooting victims, and murders" in the first nine months of the year, marking a historic low. Major crime rates, which encompass murder, rape, felony assault, and grand larceny, have also declined by 9.4 percent in the third quarter compared to the previous year.
The Common Sense Test
However, progressive politicians continue to criticize the excessive force authorized under the current police leadership. They have called for the resignation of Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch, who was appointed by Mamdani's predecessor, Eric Adams. The commissioner is appointed by the mayor and can be removed by either the mayor or the governor of New York State. According to recent reports, Governor Kathy Hochul made the retention of Tisch a condition of her endorsement for Mamdani in the upcoming mayoral election.
In response to this framing, Mamdani clarified that Hochul’s support for Tisch was "more of a recommendation" than a demand. A spokesperson for New York City Hall stated that the use-of-force review was already in progress prior to the October 8 ICE shooting and the subsequent protests, indicating that the push for reform is part of a broader strategy to address police accountability in the city.




