Polling Shows Republicans Gaining Ground Among Jewish Voters in New York
CNN chief data analyst Harry Enten recently reported that Republicans are experiencing unprecedented support among Jewish voters in New York. According to Enten, surveys reveal that the Democratic margin with this demographic has plummeted by over 35 points since 2022. This trend is particularly significant given that New York has the largest Jewish electorate in the country.
In discussing the governor's race, Enten noted that the current Democratic lead among Jewish voters stands at just 13 points, a stark contrast to the 51-point advantage held by Governor Kathy Hochul in 2022 and Andrew Cuomo's 55-point edge in 2018. "We’re talking about a swing here… of 38 points downward towards the Republicans when it comes to Jewish voters," Enten remarked.
Common Sense Shop
The United States of Common Sense
Amazon shopping links. Sponsor Complete!
The shift is not limited to the governor's race; it extends to the House races as well. The generic ballot indicates a similar trend, with the Democratic lead among Jewish voters narrowing from 49 points in 2022 to just 13 points this year. Enten quipped, "Their lead has absolutely tumbled into the Hudson River among Jewish voters."
When asked about the role of New York City’s Democratic Socialist Mayor Zohran Mamdani, Enten pointed out that Mamdani's positions on Israel and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu are misaligned with the views of many Jewish New Yorkers. His net favorability among Jewish voters is reported at minus 23, significantly lower than his standing with the overall New York electorate.
Shifts in Jewish Voter Preferences
A recent Siena University poll corroborates this trend, showing Republican Bruce Blakeman leading Hochul 46% to 43% among Jewish voters, despite Hochul's nine-point lead statewide. Jewish voters also preferred Blakeman over Hochul when it comes to addressing issues related to undocumented immigrants, with a preference of 48% to 43%. Furthermore, Mamdani's unfavorable ratings among Jewish voters stand at 64% to 33%.
Enten's analysis comes on the heels of Mamdani's election as mayor, where exit polls indicated he captured about a third of the Jewish vote. In contrast, Cuomo, running as an independent, secured approximately 63% of that vote.
The Common Sense Test
The implications of these polling trends are significant for the upcoming elections, particularly in New York's 17th Congressional District, currently held by Republican Mike Lawler. This district, which Kamala Harris narrowly carried in 2024, may see a favorable shift for Lawler if Jewish voters continue to align with the polling trends. Enten noted that prediction markets give Lawler a 39% chance of retaining his seat, a figure that could improve if the polling data holds true.
These developments underscore a critical juncture for New York Democrats, who must reckon with shifting allegiances among key voter demographics as they head into the election season.




