Supreme Court to Decide on Funding for Religious Preschools
In a pivotal case that could redefine the relationship between public funding and religious freedom, the U.S. Supreme Court is scheduled to hear oral arguments on November 3, 2026, in St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy. This case arises from Colorado's Universal Preschool Program, which aims to provide free education to every 4-year-old in the state. The program allows both public and private providers, including faith-based preschools, to participate, but requires adherence to nondiscrimination rules concerning sexual orientation and gender identity.
Catholic preschool providers, along with the parents of a preschool-age child, have challenged these nondiscrimination requirements in court. They argue that compliance would unconstitutionally burden their religious beliefs, which dictate that marriage is exclusively between a man and a woman. This legal battle highlights the ongoing struggle to balance civil rights protections with the rights of religious organizations.
Common Sense Shop
The United States of Common Sense
Amazon shopping links. Sponsor Complete!
The lower courts have largely sided with Colorado, asserting that the state’s nondiscrimination rules are neutral and generally applicable to all preschools receiving public funds. Both a federal district court and the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals concluded that Colorado was not discriminating against Catholic preschools due to their faith. Instead, they maintained that if schools accept taxpayer dollars, they cannot refuse service based on a family's identity.
This case is part of a broader constitutional debate regarding when and how religious schools can receive public support. Recent Supreme Court decisions, including Trinity Lutheran v. Comer and Espinoza v. Montana, have established that states cannot exclude religious schools from public funding solely based on their religious character. However, the 10th Circuit distinguished Colorado's program from these earlier rulings, noting that it does not bar religious schools but requires compliance with established nondiscrimination rules.
First Amendment Implications for Religious Funding
The First Amendment's two religion clauses—one prohibiting the establishment of religion and the other protecting free exercise—are at the heart of this case. Historically, the Supreme Court has held that neutral laws applying to everyone do not violate the free exercise clause, even if they conflict with religious beliefs. Thus, Colorado's nondiscrimination rule could be deemed constitutional as it applies equally to both secular and religious preschools.
However, the Supreme Court's conservative majority has expanded protections for religious institutions in recent years. In Fulton v. City of Philadelphia, the Court ruled that neutral laws lose their neutrality if the government grants exceptions based on secular interests while denying them for religious reasons. The St. Mary case presents a similar dilemma, as Colorado's program allows certain exemptions, such as giving admissions preference to church members, raising questions about whether it can deny exemptions based on religious beliefs.
The Common Sense Test
The implications of the Supreme Court's ruling could extend far beyond preschool admissions. If the Court decides that religious organizations can opt out of nondiscrimination rules while receiving public funds, it may set a precedent affecting various public funding programs. This could include challenges to existing prohibitions against discrimination based on sex or race, as seen in the historic case of Bob Jones University v. U.S., where the Court denied tax-exempt status to schools with racially discriminatory policies.
As the legal landscape evolves, the St. Mary case will likely influence how states design publicly funded programs that rely on private religious providers. The outcome could reshape the balance between protecting civil rights and ensuring religious freedom, impacting everything from universal pre-K initiatives to foster care systems and beyond. The Supreme Court's decision, expected by late spring 2027, will be closely watched as it has the potential to redefine the boundaries of religious liberty in the context of public funding.




