Ohio Appeals Court Declares School Vouchers Unconstitutional
In a significant ruling, an Ohio appeals court has declared the state’s EdChoice private school voucher program unconstitutional. This decision comes in response to a lawsuit filed by more than 300 public school districts, which argued that the program violates the Ohio Constitution by diverting taxpayer funds to private schools without the same oversight required of public schools. The court's unanimous vote highlights the ongoing debate over school funding and the rights of parents to choose educational options for their children.
The Ohio Constitution, specifically Article VI, Section 2, mandates that the General Assembly ensure a thorough and efficient system of common schools throughout the state. It explicitly states that no religious sect or group shall have exclusive control over any part of the school funds. This provision was central to the court's decision, as it underscores the need for accountability and equal access to educational resources.
Common Sense Shop
The United States of Common Sense
Amazon shopping links. Sponsor Complete!
According to the Ohio Capitol State Journal, the court's ruling does not immediately dismantle the EdChoice program, as the judges anticipate that the state will appeal the decision to the Ohio Supreme Court, which is currently dominated by a 6-1 Republican majority. This political landscape raises questions about how the highest court in the state will interpret the constitutional issues at stake.
The state Attorney General has expressed his intention to appeal the ruling, emphasizing the importance of parental choice in education. He stated that the state aims to assist parents in sending their children to the schools they prefer. However, the ruling has raised concerns among public school advocates, who argue that the voucher program undermines public education by siphoning off crucial funding and creating a system of schools that are not held to the same standards as public institutions.
Financial Implications of Voucher Programs
In fiscal year 2025, Ohio allocated over a billion dollars of taxpayer money to private school vouchers, a figure that has drawn scrutiny from critics who argue that such spending should prioritize public education. The court's decision reflects a growing sentiment that public funds should not support private educational institutions that lack the same level of oversight and accountability.
Judge Dave Leland, in his opinion, noted that the EdChoice program, as it currently stands, effectively creates a competing system of uncommon schools that are not subject to the same obligations as Ohio's common schools. This distinction is crucial in understanding the implications of the ruling and the potential consequences for the future of school choice in Ohio.
The Common Sense Test
The previous Attorney General, Dave Yost, had appealed a ruling that deemed the EdChoice program unconstitutional, but he resigned to join the conservative legal group Alliance Defending Freedom, which advocates for universal school vouchers and public funding for faith-based schools. This connection raises further questions about the motivations behind the push for school vouchers and the ongoing legal battles surrounding them.
As the case moves to the Ohio Supreme Court, the outcome will likely have far-reaching implications for educational policy and the rights of parents in Ohio. The court's ruling will not only affect the future of the EdChoice program but may also set a precedent for how state funds are allocated to education, balancing the interests of public schools with the demand for school choice and parental autonomy.




