Cook County Defends AR-15 Ban as Supreme Court Weighs Second Amendment Rights
On December 2, the Supreme Court will hear constitutional challenges to "assault weapon" bans in Connecticut and Cook County, Illinois, which include the widely owned AR-15 rifle. The plaintiffs argue that such bans violate the Second Amendment by prohibiting arms commonly used for lawful purposes. However, in briefs filed recently, Connecticut and Cook County assert that the justices should disregard the popularity of these firearms, emphasizing that the key issue is whether their restrictions align with a historical tradition of banning "unusually dangerous weapons."
Cook County and Connecticut bear the burden of demonstrating that their laws are consistent with the historical tradition of firearm regulation, as established by the Supreme Court's 2022 ruling in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen. This is no small feat, especially given the precedent set in the 2008 case District of Columbia v. Heller, which affirmed the Second Amendment protects the right to own "bearable arms" that are "in common use" for lawful purposes like self-defense. This definition clearly includes AR-15s and similar semiautomatic rifles, which are central to the current legal debates.
Common Sense Shop
The United States of Common Sense
Amazon shopping links. Sponsor Complete!
The counties argue that their regulations are similar to historical restrictions on weapons deemed excessively dangerous, citing examples such as launcegays, trap guns, and Bowie knives. Cook County claims that its ordinance targets "exceptionally lethal weapons" that are disproportionate to self-defense needs, describing AR-15s as "offensive weapons of war designed for maximum lethality" and unsuitable for self-defense. This assertion, however, is contested by many AR-15 owners who argue that these rifles are indeed effective for self-defense due to their lightweight design and ease of use.
Critics of the bans point out that the features targeted by such laws—like folding stocks and pistol grips—do not fundamentally alter a rifle's function. Moreover, AR-15s fire intermediate-caliber ammunition, which some argue makes them less lethal than shotguns or many hunting rifles that are not classified as "assault weapons."
Cook County's argument hinges on the notion that regulations must evolve alongside technological advancements, yet this raises questions about the application of constitutional principles to modern technologies. The First Amendment constrains government regulation of media that did not exist at the founding, suggesting that the Second Amendment should similarly extend to contemporary firearms.
Understanding the Broader Context of the Second Amendment
The counties also misinterpret the scope of lawful purposes under the Second Amendment. While Heller highlighted self-defense, it did not limit the right to that single use. The Second Amendment encompasses various lawful purposes, including hunting and target shooting, which are also vital to the American tradition.
The briefs submitted by Cook County and Connecticut also conflate "dangerous and unusual" with "unusually dangerous," which is a critical distinction. Historical evidence shows that 19th-century regulations targeted weapons not merely for their danger but for their association with criminal activity. This context is essential in understanding the right to bear arms, which includes commonly owned weapons by law-abiding citizens.
In January, the National Shooting Sports Foundation reported that Americans own over 32 million "modern sporting rifles," including AR-15s, with estimates suggesting that between 16 million and 25 million Americans have owned such rifles. This popularity underscores the argument that AR-15s pass the common-use test established by Heller.
The Common Sense Test
Despite these facts, Cook County maintains that ownership numbers do not exempt firearms from regulation. They assert that once a regulation is shown to pursue a legitimate public safety objective, the sheer number of owners cannot prevent its enforcement. This stance raises significant questions about the balance between public safety and individual rights under the Second Amendment.
As the Supreme Court prepares to deliberate on these issues, Connecticut and Cook County face the daunting task of convincing justices that their bans are consistent with historical traditions of firearm regulation. Given the precedents set by Heller and Bruen, their challenge appears formidable, particularly as they assert that the mere coverage of a weapon under the Second Amendment does not guarantee the right to own it. This argument, upon closer examination, seems increasingly untenable, leaving many to wonder how the Court will navigate these complex constitutional waters.




