Common Sense Shop

The United States of Common Sense

Political Satire Books

Browse political satire books on Amazon.

View Common Sense

Amazon shopping links. Sponsor Complete!

Conservative Political News and Opinion

Supreme Court to Rule on Catholic Schools' Religious Liberty in Colorado

Nov 5, 2026
Supreme Court to Rule on Catholic Schools' Religious Liberty in Colorado

The is preparing to hear a significant case regarding religious rights in the upcoming St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy. This case will determine whether can lawfully exclude Catholic schools from its universal preschool program based on their refusal to enroll students from families that do not conform to the church's teachings on marriage and sexuality. The implications of this case extend beyond the immediate parties involved, potentially impacting the broader landscape of religious liberty in America.

The Catholic plaintiffs, represented by the Becket Fund for , argue that the exclusion violates their constitutional rights under the Free Exercise Clause. Amanda Dixon, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, emphasized that the program was marketed as universal, suggesting that every child in Colorado should benefit. However, due to their religious convictions, many families have been unable to enroll their children in Catholic preschools and thus miss out on the benefits of the state-funded program.

Common Sense Shop

The United States of Common Sense

Political Satire Books
View Common Sense
Political Mugs
View Common Sense
Political T-Shirts
View Common Sense

Amazon shopping links. Sponsor Complete!

In 2020, Colorado voters approved a measure to provide funding for a program aimed at making preschool accessible to all four-year-olds in the state. Families are eligible for reimbursement covering 15 hours of preschool weekly, totaling over $6,000 annually. The program allows participation from public, private, faith-based, and secular preschools, but mandates that all participating institutions adhere to a nondiscrimination rule. This rule requires that preschools provide equal enrollment opportunities regardless of race, ethnicity, religious affiliation, sexual orientation, gender identity, income level, or disability.

The Archdiocese of Denver, which oversees 34 Catholic preschools, raised concerns about compliance with the nondiscrimination requirement, particularly regarding sexual orientation and gender identity. Despite seeking a religious exemption, the state denied their request, stating that while enrollment preference for congregants is permissible, discrimination against families based on protected characteristics is not allowed. Consequently, none of the Catholic preschools have participated in the universal preschool program.

In August 2023, the Archdiocese, along with two Catholic parishes and parents of preschool-age children, filed a lawsuit against the state, claiming their exclusion from the program infringed upon their religious freedoms. They pointed to a 2022 Supreme Court ruling that found Maine's exclusion of religious schools from a tuition-assistance program violated the First Amendment. The plaintiffs argue that Colorado's nondiscrimination rule is inconsistently applied, as exceptions have been granted to secular providers prioritizing enrollment for low-income families and children with disabilities.

The case has garnered attention not only for its implications on religious liberty but also for its potential to influence future funding for religious institutions. If the Supreme Court rules in favor of the Catholic plaintiffs, it may pave the way for more public funding to flow to religious schools, reinforcing the principle that religious institutions should not be excluded from state programs based on their beliefs.

As the case unfolds, the stakes are high for both the and the state. Colorado officials maintain that religious preschools can still teach according to their faith but must comply with the nondiscrimination mandate applicable to all providers. The outcome of this case will likely set a precedent for how religious institutions interact with state funding and the extent to which they can maintain their religious identity while participating in publicly funded programs.

The Intersection of Faith and Public Funding

The Catholic schools argue that the state's actions effectively discriminate against them because they adhere to their faith. They contend that the universal preschool program, as marketed, should include all children, regardless of their family's religious beliefs. The plaintiffs highlight that while they face exclusion, other preschools have been granted exceptions based on different criteria, such as socioeconomic status or disability, raising questions about the fairness of the state's nondiscrimination application.

As this case moves forward, it will not only test the boundaries of religious liberty but also challenge the notion of what it means to provide equal access to educational opportunities in a diverse society. The Supreme Court's decision could redefine the relationship between state funding and religious institutions, potentially allowing for greater participation of faith-based schools in public programs without compromising their core beliefs.

The Common Sense Test

Ultimately, the question remains whether the state has a compelling interest in excluding religious schools from the universal preschool program. The Catholic preschools argue that their exclusion is unjust and that Colorado's nondiscrimination rule should not come at the expense of their religious freedoms. As the Supreme Court prepares to hear this case, the outcome will resonate far beyond Colorado, influencing the ongoing national dialogue about religious liberty and the role of faith in public life. The stakes are high, and the implications of this ruling could shape the future of religious in America.

Common Sense Shop

The United States of Common Sense

Political Satire Books
View Common Sense
Political Mugs
View Common Sense
Political T-Shirts
View Common Sense
Conservative news
View Common Sense

Amazon shopping links. Sponsor Complete!

Common Sense Shop

The United States of Common Sense

Political Satire Books

Browse political satire books on Amazon.

View Common Sense
Political Mugs

Browse political mugs on Amazon.

View Common Sense
Political T-Shirts

Browse political t-shirts on Amazon.

View Common Sense
Conservative news
View Common Sense
President Trump

Donald Trump, the 45th and 47th President of the United States

View Common Sense
Charlie Kirk

One of the most prominent voices of the MAGA movement within the Republican Party

View Common Sense

Amazon shopping links. Sponsor Complete!

Across our publications

In Other News

Latest stories from other publications.

Explore all publications (opens in a new tab)